We think it sold for about the right price. We have a 78 with 31,000 original miles, and in solid condition, sounds very similar to what yours was. When we sell, $5,000 is likely what we'd ask for it. In regard to thinking you could have gotten more money for it....maybe, maybe not. And keep your eyes on what your goal was: to downsize, and you accomplished this. In regard to Craigslist, it's pretty much turned into a joke with mostly loonies inquiring. You say 9 people made appointments to buy it? Without looking at it first? Half of those folks were likely planning to scam you, and/or never show up to look at it. High ticket items like a $5,000 car invite those types of people to make your life miserable. Be greatful it sold fast and for your full asking price. I bet the buyer was tickled pink with it...it likely went to a great home and someone who appreciates it and will care for it. Now it's off your plate with one less vehicle to babysit. Was your wife crying because that pinto was her favorite? (When the day comes we sell our pinto, I will cry, too. It's handling the AZ heat ok so far). But, we think you did OK so rest easy and don't let regret eat at you.