I just got one of the $40.00 gaskets. It fit but you do have to cut to fit, not really hard. Also you need to remove the metal plate on the floor to remove and install the gasket. I would buy the new gasket and not worry about buying a used one. The new gasket fixed a long standing problem I had on my wagon, the back door leaked and made alot of noise when I when over a speed bump now no leak and no noise. Buying a used one really doesn't make any sense to me, the hatch seals differently than a door but you could use it... The shop on eBay was a fast shipper as well. I mean it's your car and your money. I'd rather spend the money and not have to worry about it for as long as I own it..I mean there are somethings I get cheap but a weatherstrip is not one of them , these things keep the water and wind out.....And keep the car from rusting where you can not see it until it's to late....I have some corrosion control to do on my car's hatch area nothing major but I'm glad I found it...